NTK Fact Check: PolitiFact on McCaskill and Private Planes NTK Fact Check: PolitiFact on McCaskill and Private Planes – NTK Network

NTK Fact Check: PolitiFact on McCaskill and Private Planes

The fact-checker wrote that a Senate Leadership Fund (SLF) ad about Claire McCaskill and private planes is "false," but quickly retracted their ruling on Tuesday evening.

By NTK Staff | 10.17.2018 @10:30am
NTK Fact Check: PolitiFact on McCaskill and Private Planes

THE CLAIM: The Senate Leadership Fund says McCaskill “even said this about private planes, ‘that normal people can afford it.'” The footage in the ad leaves out the lead-in comment that prompted McCaskill’s remark. The full footage makes it clear that McCaskill is echoing an audience member’s observation about how U.S. commercial aviation system is available to a “normal person” — not saying that ordinary Americans can afford private planes. We rate the statement False. – PolitiFact ruling

CHECKING THE CLAIM

PolitiFact declared, in a fact-check published Tuesday evening, that an ad from Senate Leadership Fund (SLF) about Claire McCaskill is “false.” The ad claims McCaskill said “normal people” can afford planes like her husband’s plane, which is a private plane and has been a subject of controversy in McCaskill’s 2018 reelection campaign.

McCaskill made the comment at a town hall in August 2017. NTK Network reviewed the moment, considered the context, and came to a different conclusion than PolitiFact.

First, the St. Louis Post-Dispatch pointed out last year that, indeed, McCaskill was having an exchange with a town hall attendee who was discussing private flyers.

According to context not included in the new ad but provided in additional video footage from the NRSC, McCaskill was responding to a comment by an audience member who was lauding the way the U.S. air traffic system handles private flyers — so that, as he put it, “a normal person can afford it.” McCaskill then repeated the phrase in her response.

She appears to have been attempting to make a joke about her previous controversy, something the ad doesn’t make clear. But she was also generally agreeing with the premise that a “normal person” can afford to fly a private plane — a premise that might make many normal people balk.

Here’s part of the exchange reviewed by NTK Network (emphasis ours):

TOWN HALL ATTENDEE: “When you go to any other country, you know, the cost of flying and aviation – say, like, if you just had a friend that went home to Greece and was traveling, flying around over there. And it costs, like, $500 if you go one little city to the next. You know, and you have to go through all kinds of – you have to have credit cards on file for them to charge your account when you get [inaudible] number. And that’s one thing that the United States has that nobody else has, is a [inaudible] fly around, and be affordable, where a normal person can afford it, you know?”

CLAIRE MCCASKILL: “Will you remind that when they come after me about my husband’s plane? That normal people can afford it.” [Laughs] “Um, yeah, but I understand the fear. And I understand the uncertainty. But I remain committed to trying to look at any solution we can find to get our stuff updated. But not at the expense of general aviation.”

NTK Network’s read of McCaskill’s quip is that her line, “normal people can afford it,” is in reference to her husband’s plane, and not the subject of general aviation. McCaskill may have been joking, as PolitiFact mused, but the reference to affordability is clearly about her husband’s plane.

PolitiFact may be thinking the same way, now. Shortly after publishing their fact-check, they unpublished the fact-check and tweeted that they’re “re-evaluating it” with “new evidence.”

RATING

PolitiFact boldly claimed that SLF’s claim was “false” for noting that McCaskill said of flying private “that normal people can afford it.” The outlet retracted their ruling after receiving “new evidence.” As of Wednesday morning, we’re waiting for an updated ruling. But PolitiFact was wrong to call SLF’s ad false just because McCaskill may have been joking. Even if she was joking, her line about affordability is a reference to her husband’s plane.

Therefore, we rate PolitiFact‘s “false” ruling, since retracted, Very Fake News.

NOTE: NTK Network’s Fact Check scale ranges from “Very Fake News,” for the most egregious false claims, to “Fake News,” “Mostly Fake News,” and, for claims that check out, “Mostly Real News” and “Real News.”

Sign Up

for NTK updates every week.


View Privacy Policy